Tuesday, January 15, 2013

Behaviorist Learning Theories and Technology-S.Karabaic Application Assignment 2


Behaviorist Learning Theories and Technology


There are many tools that  Behaviorists would encourage teachers to employ to help students make the connection to their own learning. Students in the 21st Century need to have digital tools that allow them to gain from instruction in the fastest way possible. No longer are our students like ‘The Beaver” or families like, “The  Huckstables”. For better or worse, many of our students might resemble Honey Boo Boo and Snooki and the families might be more like “Two and a Half Men”. We can not  assume that  the world has not changed since the Behaviorists reigned, and their theories coincided with the dedication and commitment to education of that time period.

Using motivational tools like spreadsheets and rubrics can help students to make the connection  between what they are doing/not doing to achieve success. Any methods that heighten students awareness of how their own actions affect outcomes can be invaluable. Some students will never get it as I am told “You gave me a C” and  they clearly do not make a connection between their lack of on task behavior, unassisted completion of a product showing level of understanding, and/or attention to detail with what  they are able to produce. My students especially have a ‘disconnect’ between what  they perceive as the task and the task itself. If I offer them a model of a paragraph, they will write the very minimum to just get the paragraph completed and done. There is not a focus in doing their very best for the sake of learning and growing. Instead, their mentality is how quickly can I get it done and move on. I visually see the way they approach their learning as assembly line workers with the tasks coming down the belt in which they have to do something with them and move quickly before the next object  moves down the line to take its place.

Unfortunately,  there is a lack of student investment or a quest to learn for the mere sake of learning. If homework is to be viewed as stated in, Using Technology In Classroom Instruction That Works, “As an extension of the classroom, homework provides opportunities for students to deepen their understanding of the content and to gain proficiency with their skills. “ (Pitler, Hubbell, Kuhn,& Malenoski, (2007).), then perhaps there needs to be a different model. Technology can help to provide a Flipped Classroom model that allows students to engage in the task of learning through connecting to the school digitally. If students were to create interesting lessons with message boards where students post and reply to posts of their peers, this format could assist students in raising their engagement and interest levels. The immediate feedback from their peers also can provide the Behaviorist’s goal of reinforcing learning. On the chart on page 19, in Key Theorists and Their Differences, B.F. Skinner’s Stimulus Response indicates that the teacher’s role is to reinforce in the way of a response, and “with immediate and appropriate feedback.” Just  imagine a scenario where a middle school student is given the assignment watching a video clip of Dr. King’s I Have A Dream speech and then posting their response on a Discussion Board, instead of reading a dull chapter in a history text book and answering questions. The immediate feedback would be incredibly more powerful than ‘just’ the teacher’s response as the students’ own peers would engage in the discussion post, too!

The Flipped Classroom has been very much in the news in the last few years and is gaining in popularity and in acceptance. In the article, Flipped Classroom Offers New Learning Path, (Bergman,2011) Jonathan Bergman was asked to define a flipped classroom, “The classic definition is kids watch videos at home for their homework and they come to class and do class work that used to be done as their homework.” Bergman went on to talk about the benefits of a Flipped Classroom model,

Number one, students become their own learners. They learn how to learn for themselves, instead of being spoon-fed. That is very powerful. Second, they become collaborators and help each other out. For teachers, they are able to differentiate since class is no longer a lecture chalk talk.(Bergman, 2011)

The  Flipped Classroom Model can put some teachers off, but I do believe this model would  support certain key pieces of Behaviorism. Students would be rewarded or receive a consequence if they were not following the flipped model. The responsibility moves from the teacher to the student and could further support the reward model of Behaviorism. Having students watch video clips at home,essentially receiving the lecture at home and then in class doing the actual application of the activity is project based learning at it’s best and offers students the immediate or close to immediate feedback, also known as stimulus and  reward. Rather than traditional drill and practice, take those same learning objectives and give them life by asking students not merely for a worksheet of fractions but instead ask them to apply their fraction understanding to a project. Reinforcement can come in the actual application of the learned objective, the demonstration to the class, and the increased student engagement and responsibility.

For the behaviorist’s strategies to work in the 21st Century,, students need to have a certain level of internal motivation. If its not there naturally, can we provide motivation to students so they can gain a higher degree of engagement in the process, by making them part of  their own learning? With digital tools, comes the potential to do more, expect more, provide more and support students in ways we could never do before. Behaviorism’s elements are spread far and wide within the educational setting. We need  to take what we like from Behaviorism and expand on them. Technology tools can help us in the areas of improving student input and output, engagement, responsibility, and achievement.

Electronic Education Report; 11/28/2011, Vol. 18 Issue 23, p1-3, 3p, retrieved January 15, 2013.

Lever-Duffy, J., & McDonald, J. (2008).Theoretical foundations (Laureate Education, Inc., custom ed.).Retrieved January 15, 2013, Boston, MA: Pearson Education.

Pitler H., Hubbell, E., Kuhn, M., & Malenoski, K. (2007).Retrieved, January 15, 2013, Using technology with classroom instruction that works. Alexandria, VA: ASCD.

3 comments:

  1. Dear Stephanie,

    Your opening paragraph brings up a very interesting component to the decline of behaviorism. This learning theory is rooted in the ideas of motivation, reinforcing incentives, and punishments. Behaviorists looked for observable changes to prove that this was how students learned. They completely disregarded the emotional component of learning and the attitudes brought toward learning by each individual they tested. Much of their work was completed during the twentieth century when attitudes toward education were different and a greater emphasis was placed on student effort.

    I am intrigued to know what the results of behaviorist tests would show for some students today. I think specifically of a past student who was rewarded with an ipad for making the honor roll. This same student, who was academically capable, had a “helicopter” parent that audited every grade earned by the child. On one project, the student earned a lower grade than they were happy with due to their omission of an important component. Using the same rubric to assess the project as had been distributed at the onset of the project, I was unable to give points for elements that were simply not present. After taking this issue all the way to a meeting with the administration, the parent was still unhappy with the grade and spent the remainder of the year nitpicking each and every grade given to the child. I wonder what impact her family dynamic and attitude toward school would play on the roles motivation, rewards, and punishments play in her learning.

    Thank you for making connections to the Flipped Classroom Model in your post; I find it interesting and exciting. I really like the idea of making students responsible for their own learning, and I can see the correlation between the Flipped Classroom Model and behaviorism. However, I do have some questions and concerns for its actual application in the classroom. For example, what do you do when a student does not complete the home portion of the learning? I understand that the child would receive an immediate consequence, but how do you move forward to having them apply their knowledge if they did not complete their learning at home? If they were to be required to view the videos or complete the readings at that point, they would miss another portion of the lesson. In addition, how do teachers handle students who do not correctly comprehend the information from the videos or come to class with misconceptions? Is there time allotted for clearing up confusion or reteaching? Have you ever tried any elements of it in your room? I would love to hear more about the practical application of this model.

    Sincerely,

    Liza Narducci

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree that there are some issues with students who 'never' complete homework and the flipped classroom model. I am not sure how teachers resolve that. I do not use the flipped classroom model myself as I don't assign homework. Generally, my students are so overwhelmed with homework from their core classes, they would not devote any quality time to my homework. Here is an article that looks at this model from several vantage points! http://www.edutopia.org/blog/flipped-classroom-pro-and-con-mary-beth-hertz

      Delete
  2. Stephanie,

    You make an excellent point about students needing motivation in order to improve their learning. As you discussed, teachers can motivate their students to complete their work to the best of their ability through today's technology tools. I like your idea about having students watch a film clip of Dr. MLK's speech and posting a response to a discussion board rather than simply reading about it in a textbook. Giving them the opportunity to view the historical event is much more meaningful and would have a greater impact. Additionally, if students posted to a discussion board where they knew they would have a larger audience that included peers, they would be much more motivated to display work that has real quality. I admit I do not know much about the Flipped Classroom model, but after reading your thoughts, I am intrigued and will explore this idea. Thanks!

    -Rena

    ReplyDelete